New Jersey Jewish News is always here for you.
We need your support now.
Your contribution will help us bring you vital news
and frequent updates about the impact of COVID-19.
Reason to believe

Reason to believe

In her letter (Beyond belief, Aug. 18), Iris Blumenau essentially argues that an atheist can be both a good person and a good Jew. I do not disagree with either point. Ms. Blumenau also provides as the reason for her loss of faith the heart-rending anecdote that as a pediatric nurse she held two babies in her arms as they died of cancer. I, too, cannot pretend to know an adequate excuse for tragedies such as these. I have often asked the same question and found all justifications to ring hollow.

That said, I can not help but wonder what planted that seed of compassion in the heart of someone who cared for and comforted dying children. And I will not accept excuses such as evolution. I find that a rather improbable answer to this particular question. You see, I too believe in the Golden Rule. Ms. Blumenau and I simply disagree over the small matter of the Rule’s ultimate origin. The same episodes that led to Ms. Blumenau’s disbelief, give me reason to believe.

Aryeh Baer

read more: